Thursday, November 19, 2026

Colorado Wants to Jail You for Saying Boys Aren’t Girls

The Supreme Court already struck down Colorado's wedding cake law for trying to control what people say.

Colorado just passed another law that could fine or jail you for refusing to call a man a woman.

One woman already suing to stop it just explained exactly why Colorado thinks this time will be different.

Jennifer Sey's XX-XY Athletics Takes on Colorado's New Pronoun Law

Jennifer Sey built a company on one simple fact: boys are not girls.

She won a national gymnastics title, spent years as a Levi's executive, and walked away from corporate life during the pandemic lockdown fights.

In 2024 she launched XX-XY Athletics to defend female athletes from male competitors.

Now Colorado wants to punish her for saying so.

Colorado's amended Anti-Discrimination Act, known as the Kelly Loving Act, now covers a person's chosen name and broadened the law's definition of gender expression.

Translation: call a biological male "he" in your own advertising, and Colorado can fine you up to $3,500 per violation.

Keep doing it, and the state can hit you with a Class 2 misdemeanor and up to 120 days in jail.

Last month, a majority of Colorado voters, about 52 percent, said yes to Proposition 134, which locks in male, female, and coed categories for K-12 and college sports.

Sey ran that campaign with more than 3,000 volunteers.

The other side outspent them by nearly $4.5 million.

Her side still won anyway.

Colorado's own legislature wrote a law that could jail her for talking about the very law she just won at the ballot box.

Colorado's Compelled Speech Defense Is Just Trust Me Bro

Colorado's lawyers told the 10th Circuit on Monday not to worry, because the state hasn't prosecuted anyone under the law yet.

Sey isn't buying it.

"Then why do you have the law? I mean, I don't trust you," she told OutKick, describing the state's position as a "trust me, bro, defense."

She's right not to trust them.

Janna Fischer, the attorney representing Colorado, told the court the businesses were seeking the right to "misgender and deadname anyone with impunity."

That's not a legal argument.

That's a tell.

Colorado isn't defending privacy or safety here.

Colorado is defending its own right to script what you're allowed to call a grown man.

Masterpiece Cakeshop to 303 Creative: Colorado's First Amendment Losing Streak

This isn't Colorado's first trip to the woodshed.

In 2018 the Supreme Court sided with Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips after Colorado tried to punish him for declining to bake a cake celebrating a same-sex wedding.

In 2023 the justices ruled again, in 303 Creative v. Elenis, that Colorado cannot force a web designer to create a message she rejects.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the majority that the First Amendment protects the right not to speak just as fiercely as it protects the right to speak.

Earlier this year, the court ruled eight to one that Colorado's so-called "conversion therapy" ban illegally dictated what counselors can say to their own clients.

Three strikes.

Same state.

Same losing argument, dressed up in a new law.

Alliance Defending Freedom attorney Jonathan Scruggs put it bluntly: "There's just double down after double down after double down," even if that means losing at the Supreme Court all over again.

Hal Frampton, the ADF attorney representing Sey, asked the obvious question out loud this week.

"When will they learn?"

Colorado Isn't Confused about Women's Sports, It's Counting on You Folding First

Colorado knows exactly what it's doing.

Every time the Supreme Court slaps this state down, Colorado's politicians don't repeal the bad law.

They rewrite it and try again, betting that businesses like Sey's will fold under the threat of fines and jail time before any court ever rules.

That's not governing.

That's a protection racket with a law degree.

And if Colorado gets away with it this time, every blue state legislature already has the blueprint ready to copy.

Governor-elect Phil Weiser has already signaled he might move to water down Colorado's new transgender sports ban, less than a month after voters approved it.

Translate that: the voters spoke, and the incoming governor is already hunting for a workaround.

Sey isn't waiting around to find out what that workaround looks like.

She says she'll "make sure everybody knows" if Weiser tries to overturn the will of the people in his first month in office.

Given Colorado's three-strike record at the Supreme Court, betting against Jennifer Sey is a bad bet.

Sources:

  • Matt Calkins, "Jennifer Sey Fights Colorado Law That Could Punish Businesses for Refusing Transgender Pronouns," Fox News, November 17, 2026.
  • Tyler O'Neil, "Why Does Colorado Keep Losing at the Supreme Court?" The Daily Signal, July 19, 2026.
  • Ashley Oliver, "Colorado's Latest Supreme Court Loss Adds to Growing String of Culture War Defeats," Fox News, April 9, 2026.
  • Lawrence J. Tjan, "Colorado Pronoun Law Faces First Amendment Challenge in Federal Court," Law Commentary, November 16, 2026.
  • Sarah Parshall Perry, "It's the First Amendment, Stupid: Supreme Court Holds That Free Speech Prevails in Challenge to Anti-Discrimination Law," The Heritage Foundation, 2026.

Related Posts