Saturday, November 21, 2026

Federal Judges Shut down McIver Immunity Bid Hours after Her Mullin Hearing Blowup

LaMonica McIver screamed at Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin that ICE is killing people.

One day later, a federal appeals court delivered its answer.

The judges just decided whether McIver gets to hide behind the Constitution.

Third Circuit Rejects McIver's Speech or Debate Defense over Delaney Hall Clash

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit refused Thursday to reconsider its own ruling against Rep. LaMonica McIver, D-N.J.

That means two of the three charges tied to her confrontation with ICE agents at Delaney Hall stay put.

McIver tried to hide behind the Speech or Debate Clause, the constitutional provision meant to protect lawmakers from being sued over floor speeches and votes.

Two of the three judges on the panel, one a Biden appointee and one a Trump appointee, ruled against her anyway.

Court documents say McIver "slammed her forearm" into a federal officer trying to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka during the May 2025 melee.

A second charge accuses her of driving both forearms into an officer while forcing her way back inside the building.

The judges ruled that shoving and striking federal officers has nothing to do with being a lawmaker.

Only Judge Thomas Ambro disagreed, arguing in his dissent that blocking a member of Congress from a facility undercuts real oversight.

Two judges said no. One said maybe. McIver loses either way.

This isn't new legal territory.

Former Rep. Rick Renzi tried the same Speech or Debate dodge in 2011, and the 9th Circuit shut him down just as fast, ruling his conduct fell "beyond the Clause's protections."

DOJ attorney Mark Coyne put it bluntly in June: "Use of physical force is never, never covered by the Speech and Debate clause."

McIver is now facing up to 17 years behind bars if convicted, and she knows it.

Inside McIver's Delaney Hall Meltdown with DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin

McIver didn't wait for Thursday's ruling to start playing victim.

One day earlier, she was in a House hearing room screaming at Mullin that his agency was killing people.

Mullin had just told her he personally visited Delaney Hall and found it in "very good condition."

McIver wasn't interested in the answer.

She interrupted him over and over, shouting "reclaiming my time" every time Mullin tried to respond with actual numbers.

She also accused Mullin, a member of the Cherokee Nation and the first Native American to hold his job, of running a racist detention system.

This is the same congresswoman who, back in June, complained that every detainee at Delaney Hall was a person of color – as if the demographics of who ICE catches breaking immigration law are somehow ICE's fault.

Mullin has called the whole circus at Delaney Hall exactly what it is: political theater, and he's right.

McIver has spent the better part of two years turning a facility doing its job into her personal campaign backdrop.

A federal court just told her the backdrop doesn't come with legal immunity.

McIver isn't an isolated case.

House Democrats across the country have made obstructing ICE oversight into a coordinated strategy, from Georgia to Maryland to Texas, using "oversight visits" as made-for-camera confrontations rather than actual fact-finding.

Lawmakers made more ICE facility visits in 2025 than the previous three years combined, and the Delaney Hall blowup is the one that finally produced an indictment.

That tells you everything about where this movement's priorities actually sit.

Democrats aren't losing sleep over detainee conditions.

They're chasing viral clips, and McIver just got a preview of what happens when the cameras stop rolling and the law shows up instead.

Her legal team is already signaling they will look for any way to keep fighting, likely including a long-shot run at the Supreme Court.

If this does reach the high court, McIver will be asking justices to rule that throwing elbows at federal agents counts as legislating.

Good luck selling that one outside a Newark press conference.

Sources:

  • Elizabeth Elkind, "Trump scores key win over House progressive accused of assaulting ICE agent," Fox News, November 19, 2026.
  • "Dem lawmakers sue ICE, demand access," The Washington Times, July 30, 2025.
  • Cameron Arcand, "Dirty Bombs and ICE Cold Clashes: Here's What You Missed From Mullin's Capitol Hill Hearing," Townhall, November 18, 2026.
  • "DHS Secretary Mullin Is Having NONE of Rep. LaMonica McIver's Anti-ICE Theatrics," Twitchy, November 18, 2026.
  • "Mullin Fires Back at Democrats During Heated Homeland Security Hearing," Legal Insurrection, November 2026.
  • "Democrat Lawmaker Is Mad DHS Isn't Locking Up Enough White Illegal Immigrants," The Daily Caller, June 3, 2026.

Related Posts

Next Post