Senate Democrats shut the government down for 43 days this year and walked away with nothing.
Now Chris Van Hollen wants to run it back over Iran.
He's threatening a shutdown while running to replace the leader who already lost this exact fight.
Van Hollen Picks a Fight He's Already Watched Schumer Lose
Van Hollen sat down with MS NOW on Thursday and didn't blink.
He wants Congress to refuse government funding on December 11 unless Trump ends the war in Iran.
"Not a penny, not a penny to fuel this war," he said, arguing Democrats shouldn't wait until January to use power they already have.
There's just one problem. Democrats already lived through this fight and lost it.
Senate Democrats held the government hostage for 43 days this year demanding Obamacare subsidies.
They caved. No subsidies. No concessions. Just furloughed workers and a party tearing itself apart over who to blame.
Van Hollen watched that disaster unfold from inside the Senate Democratic caucus.
He's proposing it again, on a different hill, as his opening pitch for Senate Majority Leader.
The Math Behind Van Hollen's Threat Doesn't Work
Here's the part Van Hollen skipped on television.
Congress doesn't control a war through a spending bill the way he's selling it.
The Constitution gives lawmakers the power of the purse. But Michael Glennon, a Tufts law professor and former war-powers counsel to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, calls the funding-cutoff argument "factually and legally untenable." Military accounts can run on money already appropriated for months, war or no war.
A joint resolution to end the war faces a presidential veto, and overriding a veto takes two-thirds of both chambers – a bar Democrats can't clear alone.
So the actual mechanism is slower, messier, and weaker than "not a penny" makes it sound.
Van Hollen knows this. He's a 23-year Capitol Hill veteran who understands how appropriations work better than most people in that building.
He's selling urgency anyway, because the midterms just proved Iran is a winning message, and MS NOW's Jen Psaki handed him the microphone to test it.
Schumer's Own Caucus Is Already Walking Away from Him
Van Hollen didn't launch this shutdown threat in a vacuum. He launched it the same day he announced he's challenging Chuck Schumer for Majority Leader.
Bernie Sanders and Elissa Slotkin both said this week they won't back Schumer.
Senators-elect Adam Hamilton, Peggy Flanagan, and Abdul El-Sayed have already said, before even being sworn in, that Schumer isn't getting their vote either.
Republican strategist Liz Mair said forcing a shutdown would be the simplest way Democrats could pressure the Pentagon on Iran – then raised doubts about whether Van Hollen could pull it off.
She questioned whether progressives are wise to place their confidence in him as a potential leader, pointing to the reputational risk Democrats would take on if the standoff played out badly.
That's a Republican operative, not a Fox panelist, raising doubts about whether the guy promising a shutdown can actually deliver one without the wheels coming off again.
Democrats Keep Running the Same Play and Keep Losing It
Walk through the last three times Democrats reached for this lever.
They threatened a shutdown over Ukraine funding back in 2023. Congress passed a short-term deal anyway, without the money Democrats wanted.
They shut down Homeland Security for weeks this year demanding ICE policy changes. DHS employees missed paychecks, and Democrats held firm even after the administration pointed to the Iran war as a reason to fund the department.
That fight over Obamacare subsidies ended the same way. Eight Senate Democrats broke ranks to reopen the government without getting what they'd demanded, and Schumer got blamed by the progressive base for folding – AOC was floated as a primary challenger to his Senate seat within days.
Van Hollen is now asking Democrats to trust him with the same weapon that has already blown up in Schumer's hands three times.
What Van Hollen Isn't Saying Out Loud
Van Hollen wants the Majority Leader job because the base is furious Schumer wouldn't fight.
So "not a penny" has to sound tougher than anything Schumer ever said, even though the underlying leverage hasn't changed at all.
It's a slogan built for a primary audience, not a strategy built to survive contact with a veto pen.
Federal workers paid the price each time Democrats tried this before.
Trump hasn't blinked through four shutdown threats, a 43-day funding standoff, and a war Democrats keep trying to defund – and he's still commander in chief making the calls in Iran.
Nothing in Van Hollen's pitch explains why round four ends any differently than rounds one through three.
Sources:
- Hanna Panreck, "Chris Van Hollen floats using government shutdown threat to force Trump to end Iran war," Fox News, November 13, 2026.
- Foreign Policy, "Why Congress Can't Stop Trump's Iran War," Foreign Policy, May 13, 2026.
- Denver Gazette, "Democrats' silence is deafening when it comes to backing Schumer," Denver Gazette, 2026.
- Fox News, "Democrats, left empty-handed in shutdown, turn fury on Schumer," Fox News, 2026.
- The Federalist, "Despite Growing Opposition and Serious Problems at Home, Democrats Make Ukraine Funding Their Top Priority," The Federalist, October 2, 2023.
- NBC News, "Democrats won't fund DHS, end shutdown despite Iran war," NBC News, 2026.










